Skip to main content

Perfectionist professors have lower research productivity

Adverse trait could seriously affect a professor’s career, new study finds.

by Léo Charbonneau

Perfectionism is sometimes viewed as a positive personality trait to be rewarded or reinforced, but Dalhousie University psychology professor Simon Sherry believes it is mostly a self-defeating behaviour.

In professors, the effect can be particularly pernicious: in a new study, Dr. Sherry and colleagues found that perfectionism leads to lower research productivity. The findings suggest that professors who display a higher level of perfectionism are less likely to produce publications, garner citations or publish their research in high-impact journals.

“We found that perfectionism trips up professors on the way to research productivity. The more perfectionistic the professor, the less productive they are,” said Dr. Sherry. This could “seriously and adversely impact” their career development. The study was published in the October 2010 issue of the Canadian Journal of Behavioural Science.

Dr. Sherry said he and his colleagues decided to look into this issue because of the continuing debate over whether perfectionism is adaptive, meaning beneficial, or maladaptive. To date, the debate has been “largely conjectural,” he said.

There are various measures of perfectionism, but most revolve around a few key definitions. “Perfectionists tend to do things perfectly – or not at all,” said Dr. Sherry. “They cannot relax until a task is ‘perfect.’ And they strive for perfection in whatever they do, requiring nothing less than perfection of themselves at all times.”

Perfectionists may also harbour crippling doubts about their abilities, which can lead to “a lot of repetitive and fruitless checking, and an exaggerated and extreme reaction to mistakes.”

These personality traits should not be confused with conscientiousness, said Dr. Sherry. “Certainly, I recognize value in achievement-striving and being goal-directed and organized and disciplined. But perfectionism is different.”

To investigate the issue, he and colleagues Paul Hewitt of the University of British Columbia and Gordon Flett of York University studied the link between perfectionism and research productivity among psychology professors working at universities in the U.S. and Canada. They limited it to their own profession to simplify the logistics and restricted it to universities with graduate programs in psychology.

They contacted 10,000 professors, of whom 1,258 responded using an online survey. The researchers found a “robust correlation” between increased perfectionism and decreased research productivity in the respondents. A higher level of perfectionism was associated with a lower number of total publications and a lower number of first-authored publications. It was also associated with a lower number of citations and a track record of publishing in journals with a lower impact rating.

“So, across several indices of quantity and quality, it looks like perfectionism – in our sample of psychology professors, at least – impedes research productivity,” said Dr. Sherry. He can’t say for certain if the findings can be generalized to other disciplines, but he suspects they could. “Perfectionism is sort of the common cold of academia. Examples abound, both good, bad and otherwise.”

If professors suspect they’re perfectionists, Dr. Sherry counsels that they seek professional help. The best treatment options appear to be interpersonal or cognitive behavioural therapy, he added.

Ironically, “perfectionists are often very reluctant to seek help because they see it as tantamount to being imperfect,” he said. As well, perfectionism itself can be a barrier to effective treatment; afflicted individuals might subconsciously sabotage their course of treatment because of unrealistic expectations.

Perfectionist profs have another reason to worry: research has linked perfectionism with depression, suicide and various forms of eating disorders such as bulimia, binge eating and anorexia.

Read also:

Combating perfectionism

Print Comments (6) Post a comment
Email Reprint Share Share

Comments on this Article

If you give value for nothing (though you have a big picture of yourself shadowed by fear of criticism) and try to look for meaning in everything, you achieve nothing. I think that is what troubles most of the “perfectionist” professors.

Posted by Mesfin Demessie, Oct 18, 2013 4:02 AM

This isn't the type of survey research we can really draw a conclusion from. Note that of the randomly selected (hopefully...) 10,000 professors, only about 12.5% responded. So, the results are heavily influenced by the response set. I think it would be safe to interpret these results in a few different ways. Perhaps, professors who are opening these types of emails in the first place, and then going ahead with the survey are avoiding the pile of work on their desks...because they don't feel like they can do it perfectly and so they put it off by completing surveys and surfing facebook and reading the latest issue of science news ;) We must always look at the the population surveyed when interpreting this kind of information. The other 7800 professors might be ignoring these emails, as they perfectionist the life out of their research :) But, it is interesting data nonetheless.

Posted by Jen, Aug 13, 2012 11:00 AM

Talk about 'research' that entirely misses the point.

The object of interest (and urgency) concerns how it is that 'perfectionism' in the academy even exists; that is, the problematic discourses of 'perfectionism', 'productivity', 'quality', ratings, and 'excellence' in higher ed.

Posted by Contrarian Librarian, Jan 17, 2012 1:24 PM

Wouldn't it be more interesting to know whether or not perfectionist professors do better research? I could care less about higher productivity if the resulting work is half-baked and uninspired.

Posted by Tenured Radical, Sep 12, 2011 1:11 PM

It's an interesting, but not surprising finding...this is in line with earlier findings by Boice's in this area as well.

Unfortunately, the MSP plan in my province doesn't cover the care to solve the problem.

Posted by Jojo, Feb 22, 2011 7:45 PM

Thanks to professor Simon Sherry, Dalhousie University psychology, for his resourceful and nice study.

I like it very much.

Posted by Absar, Feb 21, 2011 2:11 AM


Post a comment

University Affairs moderates all comments according to the following guidelines. If approved, comments generally appear within one business day. We may republish particularly insightful remarks in our print edition or elsewhere.